Applegreen Cemetery
Gerry NY

AKA Old Chautauqua HIll Road Cemetery
Compiled by PHGS member Mark Peebles
Read an account of probing the derelict cemetery

Photo by Mark Peebles


ANDRUS, Emma J. Born 3-1861, died 9-19-1861. Age: 6M - Dau of Cyrus and Clarissa (Thorn) Andrus
ANDRUS, Lydia (Ward). Spouse of Cyrus Andrus. Born 3-20-1816, died 6-26-1843. Age: 27 - Dau of James and Jane Ward, died in Gerry NY
ANDRUS, Lydia J. Born 7-28-1841, died 11-10-1852. Age: 11 - Dau of Cyrus and Lydia (Ward) Andrus, born and died in Gerry NY
BATES, Rensselaer J. Spouse of Bersheba Mosier. Born 10-19-1827, died 3-23-1859. Age: 31 - Son of James and Sally (Grover) Bates, born and died in Gerry NY
BATES, Willard R. Born 5-1857, died 5-1870. Age: 13 - Son of Renssalaer and Bersheba (Mosier) Bates. Born and died in Gerry NY
CAMPBELL Mahala Hiram Campbell. Born 1808, died 5-22-1855. Age: 46 - One son
CASE, Eliphalet. Spouse of Lavina Hutchins. Born 11-26-1769, died 4-24-1847. Age: 77 - Born in Barkhamsted CT and died in Gerry NY, eleven children
CASE, Lavina (Hutchens). Spouse of Eliphalet Case. Born 6-20-1762, died 1-4-1829. Age: 86 - Born in Bolton CT and died in Gerry NY, four children
COY, Amy (Cole). Spouse of Erastus Coy. Born 1785, died 5-20-1850. Age: 64 - Dau of Benjamin and Susanna (Spencer) Cole. Born in Shaftsbury CT and died in Gerry NY. Three children
COY, Erastus. Spouse of Amy Cole. Born 5-3-1780, died 10-3-1851. Age: 71 - Son of Benjamin and Hannah (Allen) Coy, Sr. Born in Middletown VT, died in Gerry NY, four children
ELDRIDGE, Sybil (Staples). Spouse of Sylvester Eldridge. Born 10-6-1789, died 7-22-1873. Age: 83 - Dau of Isaac and Esther (Benson) Staples. Born in Mendon MA and died in Gerry NY, nine children
ELDRIDGE, Sylvester W. Spouse of Sybil Staples. Born 2-21-1785, died 2-27-1871. Age: 86 - Son of Joseph and Barbara Eldridge. Born in Berkshire MA and died in Gerry NY, nine children
HILLIKER, Carol Ann (Potts). Spouse of Robert O. Hilliker, Sr. Born 9-26-1934, died 2-19-2012. Age: 77 - Dau of William Henry and Addie Eliz (Hughes) Potts, born in Buffalo NY and died in Silver Creek NY, two sons
HOWE, Squire, II. Spouse of Mary Townley. Born 7-20-1785, died 2-12-1855. Age: 69 - Son of Squire and Martha (Field) Howe, I. Born in Vernon VT, died in Dryden NY, nine children
PENDLETON, Laura (Case). Spouse of Eli D. Pendleton. Born 9-16-1800, died 5-7-1865. Age: 64 - Dau of Eliphalet and Lavina (Hutchins) Case, born in CT and died in Ellington NY, four children
RIDER, Eugene. Born 1-1842, died 6-26-1842. Age: 5M - Son of Nathaniel and Susanna Ryder, born in died in Chautauqua NY
RIDER, Luke H. Born 1840, died 8-17-1842. Age: - Son of Nathaniel and Susanna Ryder, born in died in Gerry NY
RIDER, Sarah Ann. Born 1837, died 10-24-1840. Age: 3 - Dau of Nathaniel and Susanna Ryder, born in died in Gerry NY
SHAW, Joseph Wesley. Born 12-20-1844, died 7-30-1864. Age: 19 - Son of Joseph Carter and Juliette (Howe) Shaw, born in Ellington NY and died in Petersburg, VA - Civil War KIA, Co B 112th Inf NYS Vols, Pvt. Enlisted 8-4-1862 at Ellington for three years. Killed in Action 7-30-1864 at Petersburg VA.
SHAW, Squire Howe. Born 11-26-1840, died 6-3-1864. Age: 23 - Son of Joseph Carter and Juliette (Howe) Shaw, born in Ellington NY and died in Cold Harbor, VA. Cenotoph, actually bd. in Cold Harbor Natl Cem, grave 324 - Civil War DOW, Co B 112th Inf NYS Vols, Cpl. Enlisted 8-4-1862 at Ellington for three years. Wounded in action 6-1-1864 at Cold Harbor VA, died of Wounds 6-3-1864 in field hospital.
THORN, John. Spouse of Mahala. Born 6-30-1875, died 12-10-1862. Age: 77 - Born in Dutchess Co NY
THORN Mahala. Spouse of John Thorn. Born 8-14-1790, died 2-19-1870. Age: 79 - Born in Columbia Co NY, two children
THROOP, Anthea. Spouse of D. Throop, died 11-1-1852. Age: 45
THROOP, Rhoda. Spouse of George Throop, died 6-23-1827




Back to Chautauqua County


If you have anything of genealogical or historical interest to add to this site, or if you are interested in becoming a member of the Painted Hills Genealogy Society, please contact us at:
Painted Hills

This page is maintained by the PHGS
Last Update February 12, 2022