COTTAGE CEMETERY
Main St Cottage RD
South Dayton, NY

from Betty Shellenbarger & Myrna Moss March 8, 2000.

Submitted by Carol Barber

ADELL, Elva. Born 1854, died 1932 Row 27 Sec. B Lot 26
ALDEN, Belle (Whiting). Spouse of David S. Born 1860, died 5-21-1904. Age: 43 Row 14 Sec. B lot 79
ALDEN, David S.Jr. Born 12-11-1896, died 9-21-1898. Age: 2y - Son of David S. & M. Belle (Whiting) Alden Row 14 Sec. B lot 79
ALDEN, David S. Sr. Spouse of #1 Delana E. Hubbard, #2 Belle Whiting. Born 9-11-1843, died 12-8-1902. Age: 59 - Son of Israel & Mary Ann (Hooker) Alden. Wed Delana1-1-1863. Wed Belle 1-1-1895 Row 14 Sec. B lot 79
ALDEN, Delana E. (Hubbard). Spouse of David S. Sr. Born 4-29-1845, died 10-6-1891 - Dau of Lucius & Harriet (Bunce) Hubbard Row 14 Sec. B lot 79
ALDEN, Elizabeth. Born 1900, died 12-16-1964. Age: 64 Row 14 Sec. B lot 78
ALDEN, Frank H. Born 1855, died 1929 Row 15 Sec. B lot 77
ALDEN, Isreal H. Spouse of Mary Ann. Born 4-1-1818, died 6-15-1883 Row 15 Sec. B lot 77
ALDEN, Mary Ann (Hooker). Spouse of Isreal H. Born 4-15-1820, died 7-1-1887 Row 15 Sec. B lot 77
BENTLEY, Annabell (Lowis). Spouse of Floyd Clarence. Born 3-22-1901, died 4-6-1970 - Dau of Salkeld & Sarah Ann (Hope) Lowis Row 25 Sec. C lot 86
BENTLEY, Floyd Clarence. Spouse of Annabelle Lowis. Born 8-13-1901, died 4-5-1989 - Son of Henry B. & Ida May (Peck) Bentley Row 25 Sec. C lot 86
BENTLEY, Henry Burt. Spouse of Ida. Born 4-6-1874, died 12-25-1960 - Son of Lieberant & Mary (Gullen) Bentley Row 24 Sec. C lot 87
BENTLEY, Ida May (Peck). Born 7-6-1880, died 12-11-1955 - Dau of Hiram & Laura (Stelley) Peck Row 24 Sec. C lot 87
BENTLEY, Laura P. Born 5-11-1906, died 12-22-1906 - Dau of Henry & Ida May (Peck) Bentley Row 26 Sec. B lot 30
BENTLEY, Mina (LeBarron). Spouse of Thomas L., died 5-13-1880. Age: 27 - Dau of Linus Sr. & Lizzy (Coon) LeBarron Row 15 Sec A
BLAIR, Charles W. Spouse of Pasorette. Born 1822, died 1897 - FATHER Row 6 Sec A
BLAIR, Emmet W. Born 1849, died 1904 Row 6 Sec A
BLAIR, Hattie. Born 1855, died 1922 Row 6 Sec A
BLAIR, Pasorette (Smith). Spouse of Charles W. Born 1826, died 1897 - Dau of Wm. D. & Betsy (Webb) Smith. MOTHER Row 6 Sec A
BLODGETT, Frank M. Born 1843, died 1911 Row 10 Sec A
BLODGETT, Lucy A. Spouse of #1 Franklin, #2 Martin R. Blodgett. Born 1808, died 1900 - Small broken stone.. possibly a Muzzy? 3 row 20
BLODGETT, Martin R. Spouse of #1 Polly Williams, #1 Lucy A. Born 4-23-1804, died 7-27-1871
BLODGETT, Polly (Williams). Spouse of Martin R. Born 5-30-1809, died 6-8-1838 - First wife of Martin.
BOROWSKI, Daniel A. Sr. Spouse of #1 ?, Terri J. (Crouse) Bartlett. Born 6-24-1958, died 3-6-2019. Age: 60 - Son of Joseph and Rita (Budzinski) Borowski. Lived in Perrysburg NY. A supermarket manager. Two children, with unnamed frist wife. Wed Teri abt 1989.
BOROWSKI, Teri J (Crouse) Bartlett. Spouse of #1 Thomas Bartlett Sr, #2 Daniel Borowski Sr. Born 11-10-1955, died 11-29-2023. Age: 68 - Dau of John & Grace (Smith) Crouse. Born in Gowanda NY, lived and died in Perrysburg NY. Worked 25 years at NYSDDSO Perrysburg NY. Two children with Thomas. Wed Daniel abt 1989.
BUNCE, Nelson, died 2-24-1917
COON, Aaron. Spouse of Amelia. Born 1831, died 1907 - Father Row 5 Sec A
COON, Amelia. Spouse of Aaron. Born 1831, died 1905 - Mother Row 5 Sec A
COON, Bert E. Born 1857, died 1937 Row 22 Sec B lot 149
COON, Dee. Born 1863, died 4-11-1879. Age: 16 - Son of Aaron and Pamelia Coon Row 5 Sec A
COON, Edith. Born 1870, died 1895 Row 5 Sec A
COON, Ella. Born 1866, died 1938 Row 19 Sec B
COON, Eunice (LeBarron). Spouse of Roland. Born 1817, died 1901 - Dau of Jemina LeBarron Row 14 Sec A
COON, Florence A. Born 1849, died 1907 Row 22 Sec B lot 149
COON, Frank. Born 1861, died 1915 Row 19 Sec B
COON, Gracie May, died 3-19-1889. Age: 8m 3d - Dau of Jay and Lillian Row 24 Sec B lot 43
COON, Hannah. Spouse of Jonathan, died 1-3-1879. Age: 78 Row 15 Sec A
COON, Henry. Born 1867, died 2-2-1867 - Son of Aaron and Amelia Coon Row 5 Sec A
COON, Hopy, died 12-28-1849. Age: 16y 10m 4d - Son of Jonathan and Hannah Row 15 Sec A
COON, Jacob, died 1-24-1850. Age: 28y 11m 16d - Son of Jonathan and Hannah Row 15 Sec A
COON, Jay. Spouse of Lillian. Born 1861, died 1918 Row 24 Sec B lot 43
COON, Jonathan. Spouse of Hannah, died 10-21-1863. Age: 66 Row 15 Sec A
COON, Kitty Iva, died 3-5-1889. Age: 1y 8m 7d - Dau of Jay and Lillian Row 24 Sec B lot 43
COON, Lillian. Spouse of Jay. Born 1861, died 1943 Row 24 Sec B lot 43
COON, Lorana M, died 12-16-1853. Age: 18y 5m 23d - Dau of Jonathan and Hannah Row 15 Sec A
COON, William, died 9-11-1875. Age: 36y 3m 27d Row 11 Sec A
DAVIS, Lillian G. (Guitson). Spouse of Owen. Born 10-15-1924, died 12-22-2017. Age: 93 - "Dau of Anthony and Frances (Smigel) Guitson. Born in Droyer PA, lived in Perrysburg NY, died in Buffalo NY. Three sons,
(Spouse predeceased)"
EDGERTON Stone Row 9 near MUZZY/ BLODGETT
GOODWILL, Robert. Spouse of Sally B., died 10-7-1996
GOODWILL, Sally B. (Marble). Spouse of Robert. Born 6-30-1932, died 3-19-2008. Age: 75 - Dau of Earle & Sadie (Moss) Marble
GREEN, Chloe LeBarron. Born 1825, died 1900 - Buried 12-17-1900. Don't know if she was a LeBarron or if she was married 1st to a Lebarron later to a Green
HOLDRIDGE, Anita E. (Babcock) [Ann]. Spouse of Benjamin S. Born 3-1-1919, died 3-14-2000. Age: 81 - Dau of James & Mary (Dion) Babcock. Wed 6-13-1947 in New York City Row 30 Sec. C
HOLDRIDGE, Benjamin S. Spouse of Anita E. Born 3-30-1919, died 3-2-1985 - Son of John & Ella (Beebe) Holdridge - WW II Vet, US Army Row 30 Sec. C
HOLDRIDGE, Orvis George "Red". Spouse of Patience Smith. Born 1-11-1914 - Son of John & Ella (Beebe) Holdridge - WW II Vet, US Army Combat Engineers, Pvt. Row 30 Sec. C lot 6
HOLDRIDGE, Patience (Smith). Spouse of Orvis "Red", died 3-21-1984. Age: 66 - Dau of Frederick & Cora Mae (Yoast) Smith. Wed 8-4-1945 Row 30 Sec. C lot 6
HOWARD, Linda L (Clees). Born 8-3-1939, died 3-8-2018. Age: 78 - Dau of Arthur L & Ruth M (Linsler) Clees; Born in Gowanda NY, died in Buffalo NY; retired as Keyboard Specialist at Fredonia State College. Three children
JOHNSON, Frances (Wheeler). Spouse of Calvin S. Born 3or5-5-1884, died 7-5-1882 Row 8 Sec A
LAFFERTY, Albert A. Spouse of Ann M Leonard. Born 1824, died 10-5-1909. Age: 85 - Son of Daniel and Catherine (Snyder) Lafferty Row 20 Sec B lot 151
LAFFERTY, Ann Maria (Leonard). Spouse of Albert A. Born 6-9-1826, died 11-2-1921 - Dau of Isaac Richmond and Lucy (Manchester) Leonard Row 20 Sec B lot 151
LAFFERTY, Daniel Wiley. Spouse of Ellen Leonard. Born 3-1833, died 7-1900 - Son of Daniel and Catherine Snyder Lafferty - Civil War Vet, Co A 64th Inf, NYS Vols, Pvt Row 20or23 Lot 115
LAFFERTY, Ellen. Spouse of Daniel Wiley, died 1914 - Int 2-21-1914 no stone
LAFFERTY, Emma B. (Blodgett). Spouse of Eugene S. Born 4-1-1851, died 2-24-1937 - Dau of Martin and Lucy Wheeler Muzzy Blodgett. Wed 11-12-1872 Row 20 Sec B lot 151
LAFFERTY, Ernest. Born ?, died ? - Int: 3-2-1916 no stone
LAFFERTY, Eugene S. Spouse of Emma B. Born 12-17-1850, died 1-5-1935 - Son of Albert and Anna Maria (Leonard) Lafferty Row 20 Sec B lot 151
LAFFERTY, Horace R. Born 1851, died 6-22-1907. Age: 56 - Son of Eliphas M. Lafferty and Emily (Lafferty) LeBarron. iinjuries from R. R. Accident - Civil War Vet Row 24 Sec B. lot 147
LAMB, Lydia (LeBarron). Spouse of Boughton, died 10-12-1875. Age: 70y 1m 22d - Dau of Alden and Jemina (Coon) LeBarron Row 12 Sec A
LEBARRON, Aaron. Born 1850, died 2-10-1913. Age: 60 - Son of Alamanson and Electa LeBarron. Born in Ellington, NY
LEBARRON, Alamanson. Spouse of Electra
LEBARRON, Alden. Spouse of Jemina Coon. Born 6-2-1775, died 9-28-1850. Age: 75y 3m 26d - Note: Row 13 has Alden LeBarron also. Maybe Jr? Row 14 sec A
LEBARRON, Alden ( Jr?). Spouse of Sally - Son of Alden and Jemina (Coon) LeBarron. Broken stone b. 1814?
LEBARRON, C. G. ( maybe "Gid") - Small stone, no dates or name. Poss. a child of Alden and Jemina? an old cemetery book shows 4/4/1910 rec'd of E. S. Lafferty for digging grave of Gid LeBarron
LEBARRON, E. S. - Small stone, no dates or name. Poss. a child of Alden and Jemina?
LEBARRON, Electa. Spouse of Alamanson. Born 1824, died 1875
LEBARRON, Emily (Lafferty). Spouse of #1 Eliphas Lafferty, #2 John H. LeBarron. Born 1833 - Dau Daniel and Catherine (Snyder) Lafferty. Wed in 1898. Interred 8-12-1915
LEBARRON, Emma. Born 1851, died 1857
LEBARRON, Hattie. Spouse of John H, died 5-13-1880. Age: 27 - Nee Coon? Row 15 Sec A
LEBARRON, Hiram. Born ?, died ? - Civil War Vet, Co A 90th Inf NYS Vols, Pvt.
LEBARRON, James, died 11-9-1865. Age: 18y 1m 16d - Son of Linus and Lizzie LeBarron
LEBARRON, Jemina Coon. Spouse of Alden. Born 1779, died ? - Broken stone - can' t read
LEBARRON, John H. Spouse of #1 Hattie, #2 Emily. Born 1845, died 1916 - Civil War Vet, Co A 90th Inf NYS Vols, Pvt.
LEBARRON, Julydia. Born 2-1-1852, died 2-2-1852 - Dau of Alden and Sally LeBarron
LEBARRON, L.C.B. Born ?, died ? - Poss. child of Alamanson and Electa LeBarron, Small stone
LEBARRON, Linus. Spouse of Lizzie, died 3-19-1882. Age: 81y 11m 24d
LEBARRON, Linus Jr. Born 1833, died 1922 - Poss. son of Linus and Lizzie. Int: 2-20-1922
LEBARRON, Lizzie. Spouse of Linus. Born 1805, died 1885
LEBARRON, Lois R. Born 1831, died 1895
LEBARRON, Myrtle. Born 1867, died 1878 - Dau of Alamanson and Electa LeBarron?
LEBARRON, Sally. Spouse of Alden Jr - No stone
LEBARRON, Seneca. Born 1827, died 1874
LEONARD, Isaac R. Spouse of Lucy A, died 2-6-1861. Age: 69y 1m 27d - Uncategorized Vet Row 17 Sec A
LEONARD, Joseph N. Spouse of Maryette Edgerton. Born 1820, died 1910 Row 19 Sec B lot 152
LEONARD, Lucy A. Spouse of Isaac R., died 10-5?-1853. Age: 36Y? 1m 7d Row 17 Sec A
LEONARD, Maryette (Edgerton). Spouse of Joseph N. Born 1830, died 1905 Row 19 Sec B lot 152
LEONARD, Maryette R., died 10-21-1849. Age: 18y 7m 1d - Dau of Isaac R. and Lucy A. Leonard Row 17 Sec A
LEONARD, Schulyer B., died 10-17-1849. Age: 20y 11m 2d - Son of Isaac R. and Lucy A. Leonard Row 17 Sec A
MATTESON, Royce E. Spouse of Jeanne Matteson. Born 8-10-1937, died 7-10-2022. Age: 84 - Son of Kenneth and Marian ( Brown) Matteson; born in Cottage, NY, died in South Dayton, NY; worked @ Town of Dayton Highway Dept
MCDONALD, Michael. Born 12-3-1955, died 9-29-2021. Age: 65 - Son of Paul and Helen ( Holland) McDonald; born in Buffalo, NY, died in Ocala, Fla. Of Perrysburg, NY; 2 children survive
MUSSELL, Margaret A. (Goodrich). Spouse of Robert J. Born 1-26-1924, died 5-14-2010. Age: 86y - Dau of Earl S. & Anna (Dolland) Goodrich. Born in Buffalo-NY Wed 12-27-1942 (Spouse d. 8-19-2001) 3 row 20'
MUZZY, Franklin. Spouse of Lucy A. Born 9-11-1797, died 10-11-1838 Row 9 Sec 1 ( 2nd 20' area from Cottage Rd)
MUZZY/BLODGETT, Aschsah. Born 7-13-1834, died 4-2-1862 Row 9 Sec 1
MUZZY/BLODGETT, Harvey P. Born 9-5-1835, died 12-14-1858 Row 9 Sec 1
MUZZY/BLODGETT, Luzen. Born 3-5-1833, died 3-1-1861
RANDALL, Henry. Born 1835, died 1898 - Civil War Vet, Co B 154th Inf NYS Vols
REDFIELD, Samuel Dr. Spouse of Nancy Fairchild. Born 9-18-1762, died 1837 - Wed 5-18-178 (spouse b. 8-3-1763 Guilford CT, d. 1-10-1845) - Revolutionary War. He served in the Conn. Troops and is said to have been a fifer
RUGG, Mandane Muzzy. Born 1837, died 1891 - Mandane Muzzy married Dr. Jonathan G. Rugg (also has a stone at West Perrysburg Cemetery)
SHELLENBARGER, John. Born 11-7-1956, died 12-14-1973. Age: 17 - Son of Richard & Betty (Smith) Shellenbarger
SHELLENBARGER, Richard D. Spouse of Betty L. Smith. Born 7-11-1931, died 9-17-2006. Age: 75 - Son of William E. and Isabelle (Wyatt) Shellenbarger. Born in Smithboro NY. Wed 7-2-1955 - Cold War Vet, US Navy
SNYDER, Clarence. Born 1896, died 1959 Row 32 Sec B.lot 13
SNYDER, Hattie. Born 1901 Row 32 Sec B.lot 13
SNYDER, Norene A. Born 8-5-1930, died 8-6-1930 Row 32 Sec B.lot 13
UNKNOWN Small stone Row 15 Sec A
UNKNOWN Small Stone Row 15 Sec A
VOLK, George J. Spouse of Lillian P, died 1-8-1-8-1999 - Wed 11-16-1940
VOLK, Lillian (Pagett). Spouse of George J. Born 8-5-1913, died 11-6-1999 - Dau of Garland and Betsy (Meyers) Pagett
WATSON, Patricia M. (Cole). Spouse of Robert E. Watson. Born 1-28-1935, died 4-19-2023. Age: 88 - Dau of Dr Allen & Lucille (Searle) Cole; Born in Gowanda, NY, died in Buffalo, NY. Three children
WINSHIP, Don B. Spouse of Mary Lou. Born 7-5-1929, died 2-25-2010 - Son of Fred G. & Veronica (Burns) Winship, b. Springville NY




If you have anything of genealogical or historical interest to add to this site, or if you are interested in becoming a member of the Painted Hills Genealogy Society, please contact us at:
Painted Hills

This page is maintained by the PHGS
Last Update April 17, 2024