Dayton Catholic Cemetery

AKA St. Paul of the Cross Cemetery
Town of Dayton, NY
US Route 62 in the Town of Dayton
Submitted by Judith Quinn


ADAMCZYK, Stephen. Born 1917, died 1977. Age: 60 - Died near Town of Dayton NY
ARRIGAN, James. Spouse of Mary. Born 1799, died 11-1-1874. Age: 75 - Born in County Waterford Ireland, died near Dayton NY; father of Kate Arrigan
ARRIGAN, Kate. Born 1846, died 11-23-1873 - Dau of James & Mary Arrigan
ARRIGAN, Mary. Spouse of James. Born 1810, died 3-6-1880. Age: 70 - Mother of Kate Arrigan
ARRIGAN, Thomas. Born 1840, died 6-9-1871. Age: 31 - Son of James & Mary Arrigan
BALL, Anna R. Spouse of Lewis E. Born 1866, died 1937. Age: 71 - Died near Town of Dayton NY
BALL, Leason J. Spouse of Ellen L Abbott. Born 4-27-1894, died 6-6-1929. Age: 35 - Born in Pittsburgh PA, died Town of Hanover Chautauqua Co NY; Wed 11 -11- 1918 Dayton NY Certif #20434
BALL, Lewis E. Spouse of Anna R. Born 1870, died 1940. Age: 70 - Died near Town of Dayton NY
BASINGER, Antone. Born 1839
BECKMAN, Baby Girl. Born 1978, died 1978 - Dau of Denise Ann Beckman
BECKMAN, Denise Ann. Born 1945, died 1978. Age: 33 - Mother of Baby Girl Beckman
BENTLEY, Bessie (Langham). Spouse of John J Bentley. Born 7-3-1886, died 11-8-1960. Age: 74 - Dau of Richard Tayler & Ella Lydia (Crooks) Langham; Born in Corydon Township McKean Co PA, died in South Dayton NY
BENTLEY, John J. Spouse of Bessie Langham. Born 8-19-1879, died 11-16-1969. Age: 90 - Son of Mary Bentley; Born & died in Cattaraugus Co NY
BENTLEY, Liberat. Born 1826, died 1896. Age: 70
BENTLEY, Mary. Born Mar 1847, died 11-27-1925. Age: 78 Died in Markhams, Town of Dayton NY; mother of John J Bentley (1879-1969)
BERSINGER, Joseph - Unable to read information - Top of stone sticking out of the ground
BLASZAK, Helen Ludwika. Born 3-27-1911, died 8-22-1913. Age: 2
BUBACH, Agnes F. Born 4-22-1861, died 12-18-1877. Age: 16y 7m 26d - Dau of George A & Carolina (Staub) Bubach
BURNS, Anna. Born 1864, died 1943. Age: 79 - Dau of Michael & Mary Burns
BURNS, James. Born 1866, died 1943. Age: 77 - Son of Michael & Mary Burns
BURNS, John. Born 1863, died 1865. Age: 2 - Son of Michael & Mary Burns
BURNS, Mary (MacFarland). Spouse of Michael Burns Sr. Born 1828, died 1912. Age: 84 - Died in nearTown of Dayton NY
BURNS, Michael Jr. Born 1869, died 1943. Age: 74 - Son of Michael & Mary Burns
BURNS, Michael Sr. Spouse of Mary MacFarland. Born 1828, died 1901. Age: 73 - Died in near Town of Dayton NY
CANTILLON, James. Spouse of Sybil MacFarland. Born 1823, died 1893. Age: 70
CANTILLON, Sybil "Sibbie" (MacFarland). Spouse of James Cantillan - Born in Ireland, died in Town of Persia NY
CANTLIN, James, died 11-6-1896. Age: 38y 4m 3d - Tall stone
CANTLIN, Mary Jr, died 6-3-1928 - Dau of William & Mary Cantlin - Tall stone
CANTLIN, Mary Sr. Spouse of William Cantlin. Born 1839, died 1910. Age: 71 - Tall stone
CANTLIN, William Jr. Born 1868, died 7-13-1891. Age: 23y 3m 12d Son of William & Mary Cantlin - Tall stone
CANTLIN, William Sr. Spouse of Mary. Born 1831, died 6-15-1887. Age: 56 - Tall stone
CARNEY, Andrew. Spouse of Margaret, died 5-1-1883 - Father of Margaret & Eliza Carney
CARNEY, Eliza, died 1-3-1878. Age: 25 - Dau of Andrew & Margaret Carney
CARNEY, Margaret. Spouse of Andrew Carney, died 1891. Age: 70 - Mother of Margaret & Eliza Carney - Stone flat on the ground
CARNEY, Margaret, died 1-23-1879 - Dau of Andrew & Margaret Carney
CLARK, Bridget. Spouse of Thomas Clark. Age: 65 - Unable to read information - Top of stone sticking out of the ground
CLARK, Thomas. Spouse of Bridget. Age: 67 - Unable to read information - Top of stone sticking out of the ground
COLLINS, Cornelius"Con". Born 1852, died 1909. Age: 57 - Son of Timothy & Margaret Collins
COLLINS, Margaret. Spouse of Timothy Collins. Born 5-5-1813, died 12-17-1887. Age: 74 - Mother of Cornelius Collins
COLLINS, Timothy. Spouse of Margaret. Born 1816, died 11-29-1876. Age: 60 - Born in County Cork Ireland
COLLINS, Timothy Jr. Born 8-6-1855 - Son of Timothy & Margaret Collins
CONNORS, Ellen. Spouse of Jerimiah Connors. Born 1838, died 1-4-1923. Age: 85 - Born in Ireland, died in Dayton NY; Oldest resident Village of Dayton NY
CONNORS, Jerimiah "Jerry". Spouse of Ellen. Born 1828, died 1910. Age: 82 - Born in Ireland, died in Dayton NY
CONNORS, Johana P, died 3-30-1883 - Dau of Jerimiah & Ellen Connors
CONNORS, John. Born 1866 - Son of Jerimiah & Ellen Connors
CONNORS, Katherine. Born 1861 - Dau of Jerimiah & Ellen Connors
CREAMER, Thomas. Born 1785, died 5-29-1862. Age: 77
DAVIS, Bently Lynn. Spouse of Emma J Dole. Born 5-30-1887, died 10-28-1924. Age: 37 - Born in New Albion NY, died in Dayton NY
DAVIS, Emma J (Dole). Spouse of #1 Bently Lynn Davis #2 Parke Leland Blasdell. Born 4-4-1887, died 4-20-1964. Age: 67 - Dau of Albert S & Catherine (Geiger) Dole; Born in Perrysburg NY, died in Gowanda NY
DERMONT, Farron V. Born 3-20-1874, died 6-30-1881. Age: 7 - Son of Thomas & Irene Dermont - Stone flat on the ground
DERMONT, Thomas, died Jul 1929 - Died on Maple Hill Town of Persia NY - No Stone
DOLE, Albert S Sr. Spouse of Catherinet Geiger. Born 1872, died 1962. Age: 90 - Lived in Perrysburg NY
DOLE, Catherine (Geiger). Spouse of Albert Dole Sr. Born 1875, died 1957. Age: 82 - Lived in Perrysburg NY
ERDMANN,Robert H. Spouse of #1 June, #2 Gloria, #3Toni Bova. Born 7-7-1936, died 1-18-2023. Age: 86 - Son of Henry & Margaret Erdmann; Born in Mansfield NY on family farm, lived in Mansfield, NY
FITZMORRIS, James. Born, died 1-25-1875 - Son of Garrett & Margaret Fitzmorris
FITZMORRIS, Margaret. Born 8-7-1797, died 8-9-1891. Age: 94 - Born in Ireland
FOX, Alice. Born 1865, died 1878. Age: 13 - Born & died near Dayton NY
FOX, Ann (Gumsey). Spouse of William Fox. Born 1833, died 1921. Age: 88 - Dau of John & Esther Gumsey; Born in Ireland, lived in Leon NY; 11 children
FOX, Anna M. Spouse of John J Fox. Born 1847, died 1913. Age: 66
FOX, Caroline. Born 1870, died 1870 - Dau of William & Ann (Gumsey) Fox; Born & died near Leon NY
FOX, John J. Spouse of Anna M. Born 1834, died 1902. Age: 68
FOX, Mary. Born 1863, died 1877. Age: 14 - Dau of William & Ann (Gumsey) Fox; Born & died near Leon NY
FOX, Mary Isabelle. Spouse of Thomas Fox. Born 1838, died 1914. Age: 76
FOX, Thomas. Spouse of Mary Isabelle. Born 1835, died 1917. Age: 82
FOX, William. Spouse of Ann. Born 1825, died 1868. Age: 43 - Born in Wicklow Co Parrish of Killquay Ireland; worked as a farmer in Leon NY; 11 children
FREEMAN, Delia May. Spouse of CW Freeman. Born 5-18-1862, died 9-13-1896. Age: 34
GEIGER, Arthur H. Born 1908, died 1908 - Infant son
GEIGER, Edward V. Born 1893, died 3-10-1919. Age: 26 - Son of JH & Emma Geiger
GEIGER, Emma B. Born 1882, died 1-22-1896. Age: 14y 3m 7d - Dau of JH & Emma Geiger
GEIGER, Emma M. Spouse of JH Geiger. Born 1854, died 6-2-1919. Age: 65y 1m 13d - Parents born in Germany; lived in Erie Co NY & then in Perrysburg NY
GEIGER, John H. Spouse of Emma M. Born 1852, died 12-6-1923. Age: 71y 7m 22d - Parents born in Germany; lived in Erie Co NY & then in Perrysburg NY; worked as a farmer
GENTILE, James. Spouse of Rose Marie Mehle. Born 1871, died 1969. Age: 98
GENTILE, Nancy. Born 1816, died 1920. Age: 4 - Dau of James & Rose Marie (Mehle) Gentile
GENTILE, Pat. Born 1905, died 1976. Age: 71
GENTILE, Rose Marie (Mehle). Spouse of James Gentile. Born 1883, died 4-21-1920. Age: 37
GIANNINI, Henry. Born 1863, died 10-15-1928. Age: 65 - Born in Switzerland, died in Town of Perrysburg NY - No Stone
GRANTHAM, Bridget (Butler). Spouse of John Grantham. Born 1832, died 4-15-1874. Age: 42 - Born in Ireland; mother of Theresa (Grantham) Leach - Broken Stone
GRANTHAM, John. Spouse of Bridget Butler. Born 1820, died 7-7-1877. Age: 57 - Born in Ireland, died in Town of Persia NY - Stone flat on the ground
GUZZETTA, Mary P. Born 1907, died 1976. Age: 69
HAYES, Julia (Fox). Born 1855, died 1930. Age: 75 - Dau of William & Ann Fox (this cemetery)
HOGAN, Elizabeth. Born 1849, died Jan 1864. Age: 14 - Dau of Patrick & Ellen Hogan - Stone flat on the ground
HOGAN, Ellen, died 11-20-1878. Age: 8 - Dau of Francis & Ellen Hogan
HOGAN, Ellen. Spouse of Francis Hogan - Mother of Ellen Hogan
HOGAN, Francis. Spouse of Ellen, died 1-5-1879. Age: 60 - Father of Ellen Hogan
HOGAN, James, died 11-25-1878. Age: 18 - Son of Francis & Ellen Hogan
HOGAN, Margret - Dau of Patrick & Ellen Hogan
HOGAN, Mary Ann. Born 1856 - Dau of Francis & Ellen Hogan
JAGOW, Rita P. Born 1915, died 2002. Age: 87 - "Sister, Mother, Granny"
KELLEY, Catharine. Spouse of James Kelley. Born 1821, died 8-24-1867. Age: 46
KELLEY, James. Spouse of Catharine. Born 1819, died 1905. Age: 86
KELLEY, Mary. Born 1843, died 1898. Age: 55
KENNEDY, Mary Ann. Spouse of JM Kennedy, died 2-22-1875. Age: 25
KIRK, Jack, died 11-21-1911 - Died in Conewango NY train accident - No Stone
LANNING, Harry Thomas. Spouse of Jane Anne Cantlin. Born Nov 1880, died 6-8-1941. Age: 60 - Son of Patrick J & Mary Ellen (Caddigan) Lanning; Died in Salamanca NY; Worked @ Erie Railroad; Wed 9-21-1920 in Albion PA
LANNING, Jane Anne (Cantlin). Spouse of Harry Thomas Lanning. Born 1882, died 1954. Age: 72 - Dau of William & Mary Cantlin (this cemetery)
LORD, Barbara (Arrigan). Spouse of Leroy Lord. Born 1846, died 1916. Age: 70 - Stone flat on the ground
LORD, Leroy. Spouse of Barbara Arrigan. Born 1841, died 1928 - Stone flat on the ground
LORE, Dorothy Irene (Wagenblatt). Spouse of William Vernon Lore. Born 4-20-1918, died 5-10-2002. Age: 84 - Born in Eden Erie Co NY, died in Florida
LORE, John. Companion of Diana Goulding. Born 6-9-1946, died 12-7-2016. Age: 70 - Son of William Vernon & Dorothy Irene (Wagenblatt) Lore; Born in Gowanda NY, died in Dunkirk Chautauqua Co NY; owned & operated Phase 2 Automotive in Gowanda & Little Valley NY; 2 sons - Vietnam Vet, US Army - No Stone
LORE, William Vernon. Spouse of Dorothy Irene Wagenblatt. Born 1-31-1916, died 12-31-1975. Age: 59 - Son of William Henry Lore; Born in Butler PA, died in Gowanda NY
LUNGEY, Catherine "Kate". Spouse of Patrick Lungey, died 11-8-1913. Age: 68 - Born in Ireland, lived in Perrysburg NY
LUNGEY, James. Born 1872, died 8-20-1942. Age: 70 - Son of Patrick & Kate Lungey; "Brother"
LUNGEY, John F. Born 1878, died 1899. Age: 21 - Son of Patrick & Kate Lungey
LUNGEY, Patrick. Spouse of Catherine "Kate" 1840, died 2-15-1883. Age: 47 - Born in Ireland, lived in Parrysburg NY
LUNGEY, Patrick 1876, died 1944. Age: 68 - Son of Patrick & Kate Lungey
MCFARLAND, Allen. Spouse of Mary. Born 1838, died 1-23-1907. Age: 69 - Born in Ireland, died in Town of Persia NY
MCFARLAND, Angeline (Peters). Spouse of John C McFarland. Born 1852, died 4-5-1916. Age: 64 - Died in Town of Dayton NY
MCFARLAND, Anna G. Born 1879, died 1903. Age: 24
MCFARLAND, Bridget. Spouse of Myles McFarland, died 1-8-1899. Age: 83 - Broken Stone
MCFARLAND, Charles Peter. Born 2-5-1867, died 5-11-1895. Age: 28 - Son of Allen & Mary McFarland; Born in Town of Persia NY, died in Buffalo NY
MCFARLAND, Hugh R. Born 1895, died 10-18-1918. Age: 23 - - WW I KIA, US Army, Co B 325th Inf, Pvt. Killed in Argonne
MCFARLAND, James, died 4-18-1882. Age: 4m - Son of John & Angeline McFarland
MCFARLAND, John. Spouse of Grace. Born 1865, died 9-28-1937. Age: 72 - Son of Allen & Mary McFarland; Born in Town of Persia NY, died in Dunkirk Chautauqua Co NY; unmarked grave in McFarland family plot - No Stone
MCFARLAND, John - Stone not legible
MCFARLAND, John C. Spouse of Angeline Peters. Born 1835, died 1918. Age: 83 - At least 5 children
MCFARLAND, John P. Born 1888, died 1-15-1944 - Died in Gowanda NY
MCFARLAND, Mary. Spouse of Peter. Born 8-25-1858, died 1937. Age: 79 - Born in Ireland, died in Town of Dayton NY
MCFARLAND, Mary. Spouse of Allen McFarland. Born 1841, died 1894 - Born in Ireland, died in Town of Persia NY
MCFARLAND, Mary (Mooney). Spouse of Thomas McFarland, died Mar 1870
MCFARLAND, Mary E. Born 1871, died 1872. Age: 21 - Dau of Allen & Mary McFarland
MCFARLAND, Myles. Spouse of Bridget, died 9-9-1887. Age: 80 - Broken Stone
MCFARLAND, Patrick. Born Jan 1869, died 10-27-1928. Age: 59 - Son of Allen & Mary McFarland; Born & died in Town of Persia; unmarked grave, buried in McFarland plot
MCFARLAND, Patrick. Born 1852, died 1905. Age: 53
MCFARLAND, Peter. Spouse of Mary. Born 1850, died 1919. Age: 69
MCMAHON, Bridget, died 2-9-1885 - Dau of Michael & Rosy McMahon
MCMAHON, Mary. Born 1856, died 1934. Age: 78
MCMAHON, Michael. Spouse of Rosa. Born 1829, died 1909. Age: 80
MCMAHON, Rosa. Spouse of Michael McMahon. Born 1828, died 1908. Age: 80
MEDIO, Antonio. Born 1905, died 1976. Age: 71
MILKA, Ignatz Frank. Spouse of Catherine Nowicka. Born 1879, died 12-16-1922 - Born in Poland or Germany, died in South Dayton NY; father of Edward, Cecia, Carl & Henry; worked in milk plant - No Stone
MILKS, Clayton F Jr. Spouse of Bertha Szymanski. Born 1-24-1926, died 2-23-2018. Age: 92 - Son of Clayton F & Clara (Volk) Milks; Worked @ Town of Dayton x 50+yrs and operated a dairy farm; enjoyed the outdoors and bowling; Wed 5-14-1949in South Dayton (Spouse predeceased 9-29-2010) - No Stone
MORAN, John Joseph. Spouse of Catherine. Born 5-22-1883, died 12-7-1929. Age: 46 - Son of Martin & Katherine Moran; Born in Dayton NY, died in Gowanda NY - No Stone
MORAN, Katherine. Spouse of Martin Moran. Born 1850, died 1912. Age: 62 - Mother of John & Mary
MORAN, Martin. Spouse of Katherine, died 12-10-1928 - Born in New Ross County Wexford Ireleand, died in Town of Dayton NY; two children - No Stone
O'DONNELL, William J - Son of William & Theresa O'Donnell - Stone not legible
OLEJNICZAK, Michael. Spouse of Maria Wierzbowski. Born 9-29-1867, died 4-7-1936. Age: 68 - Son of Stephen; Born in Poznan Wielkopolskie Poland, died in Town of Dayton NY; naturalized citizen in 1895; Wed 1895/6. twelve or thirteen children - No Stone
PHILLIPS, Charles E. Spouse of Eileen M. Born 1893, died 1980. Age: 87
PHILLIPS, Eileen M. Spouse of Charles E Phillips. Born 1910, died 1982. Age: 72
POWERS, Alice. Born 1879, died 1955. Age: 76
POWERS, Florence. Born 1919, died 1981. Age: 62 - "Sister"
POWERS, Gerald. Born 1908, died 1982. Age: 74 - "Brother"
POWERS, John C. Born 1885, died 1956
POWERS, Katherine C. Born 1914, died 1994 - "Sister"
POWERS, Vincent - Mentioned on Connors stone
QUACKENBUSH, Anna (Spire). Spouse of Herman Quackenbush. Born 2-25-1872, died 8-22-1894. Age: 22 - Dau of Andrew & Pauline Christina (Powser) Spire
SCHROTT, John. Spouse of Mary A. Born 1815, died 1898. Age: 83 - Lived in Cattaraugus Co NY
SCHROTT, Mary A. Spouse of John Schrott. Born 1819, died 1883. Age: 64 - Lived in Cattaraugus Co NY
SEAVER, Gertrude. Spouse of Luke Seaver. Born 1856, died 1922. Age: 66 - Dau of George J & Maria Buckheit; parents born in Germany, lived in Buffalo NY & then in Perrysburg NY
SEAVER, Luke. Spouse of Gertrude Buckheit. Born 1857, died 1936. Age: 79 - Born in New York; worked as a baggage manager; lived in Buffalo NY & then in Perrysburg NY
SEXTON,Thomas, died 10-17-1929. Age: 59 - Died in Perrysburg NY - No Stone
SMITH, Charles, died 2-12-1868. Age: 52 - Stone flat on the ground
SPIRE, Andrew. Spouse of Pauline Christina Powser. Born 1834, died 1-22-1912. Age: 78 - Died in Town of Dayton NY
SPIRE, Christine. Spouse of Peter Spire, died 11-11-1879. Age: 36 - Stone flat on the ground
SPIRE, Otto. Born 7-23-1870, died 4-1-1895. Age: 24 - Son of Andrew & Pauline Christina (Powser) Spire - Stone flat on the ground
SPIRE, Pauline Christina (Powser). Spouse of Andrew Spire. Born Mar 1845, died 11-28-1915 - Died in Town of Dayton NY; mother of Otto & Anna
TOWN, Bridget. Spouse of William Town. Born 1852, died 1877. Age: 24
VAIL, Kattie. Born 1878, died 7-2-1885. Age: 7 - Dau of Michael & Susan Vail - Stone flat on the ground
WACHTER, Frederick. Spouse of Julia. Born 9-26-1834, died 4-30-1894. Age: 59 - Born in Aargau Switzerland, lived & died in Town of Dayton NY; six children
WACHTER, Julia. Spouse of Frederick Wachter. Born 1833, died 1901. Age: 68 - Dau of Timothy & Margaret O'Neill; Born in Ireland, lived & died in Town of Dayton; six children
WACHTER, William R. Born 3-10-1857, died 6-4-1891. Age: 34 - Son of William R & Julia Wachter
WAGNER, Susana. Spouse of Theodore Wagner. Born 1839, died 9-12-1868. Age: 29
WAGNER, Theodor. Spouse of Susana. Born 1837, died 10-15-1868. Age: 31
WARD, John. Spouse of Mary. Born 1826, died 1866. Age: 40
WARD, M. Born 1875, died 1916. Age: 41
WARD, Mary. Spouse of John. Born 1831, died 1891. Age: 60
WARD, O H. Born 1873, died 1923. Age: 50
WARD, P. Born 1867, died 1908. Age: 41
WELLS, Josephine (Geiger). Born 1877, died 1900. Age: 23 - Dau of John H & Emma M Geiger- this cemetery
YANIC, Joe. Born 12-6-1911, died 6-29-1924. Age: 12


Back To Cattaraugus County



If you have anything of genealogical or historical interest to add to this site, or if you are interested in becoming a member of the Painted Hills Genealogy Society, please contact us at:
Painted Hills

This page is maintained by the PHGS
Last Update August 29, 2023