St. Johns Cemetery
Town of Andover, Allegany County
This cemetery is located in Andover overlooking Independence Road. just off RT 17 on the Greenwood road.
It sits on a hillside with moss covered steps leading up to the Cemetery. It is also sometimes called The Old Catholic Cemetery
Originally walked & photos by Donna Allen & William Baker Sept. 2003



BAKER Elizabeth. Spouse of Michael - His Wife no other info
BAKER James. Spouse of Margaret. Born 1844, died 1906
BAKER Margaret. Spouse of James. Born 1848, died uncut - His Wife
BAKER Michael, died 4-24-1864. Age: 21y10m15d - Son of Michael & Elizabeth Baker
BAKER Michael. Spouse of Elizabeth, died 5-9-1880. Age: 84y
BAKER Patrick. Born 1827, died 1903
BAKER Thomas. Born 1852, died 1887
BAKER Timothy - no other info
BARRETT Margaret, died 8-13-1895. Age: 5y - In Memory of our sisters may their souls rest in peace
BARRETT A. Elizabeth. Born 1878, died 1948
BARRETT Iva M. Born 1876, died 1909
BARRETT Julia Evelyn. Born 1919, died 1920
BARRETT Kate, died 2-24-1865. Age: 27y - In Memory of our sisters may their souls rest in peace
BARRETT Mary. Spouse of Patrick. Born 1845, died uncut
BARRETT Patrick. Spouse of Mary. Born 1841, died 1919 - Civil War DOW, Co E 72nd Inf NYS Vols. Capt. Enrolled at Dunkirk 5-16-1861 for three years. Wounded in action 5-5-1862, died of wounds 5-6-1862 at Williamsburg VA.
BARRETT Robert M. Born 1871, died uncut
BREIDING Cresceny. Spouse of John A. Born 1878, died 1928
BREIDING John A. Spouse of Cresceny. Born 1858, died 1937
BUCHWALD Mary Dean. Born 1902, died 1941
CANNON James. Born 11-24-1881, died 3-27-1908 - Son of Michael & Margaret Cannon
CANNON James. Born 1830, died 1920. Age: 90y
CANNON James J. Born 1895, died 1901 - Son of Michael & Margaret Cannon
CANNON Joseph - no other info
CANNON Josephine - no other info
CANNON Margaret. Spouse of Michael. Born 9-28-1859, died 12-12-1930 - His Wife
CANNON Matthew - no other info
CANNON Michael. Spouse of Margaret. Born 2-15-1852, died 7-1-1937
CASEY Ellen E. Spouse of John. Born 1870, died 1953
CASEY James. Spouse of Mary. Born 1818, died 1907
CASEY John. Spouse of Ellen E. Born 1855, died 1918
CASEY Mary. Spouse of James. Born 1830, died 1892 - His Wife
CLANCY Edward. Born 1884, died 1949
CLEARY Michael, died 1-29-1869. Age: 45y - Born in Ireland Beloved he lived In Peace he died His life was traveled by God's side
CONROY Bridget. Born 1795, died 1877
CONWELL John. Spouse of Margaret, died 11-4-1902. Age: 78y
CONWELL Margaret. Spouse of John, died 2-15-1897. Age: 65y - His Wife
COONEY Bridget. Spouse of James - His Wife no other info
COONEY James. Spouse of Bridget, died 1-29-1882. Age: 69y
COREY Carolyn, died 10-26-1913
COREY William. Born 8-13-1848, died 4-8-1925 - Civil War Vet, US Navy
CUMMINGS George W. Born 1858, died 1925
DAHILL Catherine. Spouse of Timothy Sr. Born 1835, died 1895
DAHILL Dennis J, died 9-5-1897. Age: 1y 10m - Son of Thomas & Mary Dahill
DAHILL Eleanor. Born 1860, died 1929
DAHILL Timothy Jr. Born 1868, died 1928 - Son of Timothy & Catherine Dahill
DAHILL Timothy P, died 8-6-1889. Age: 5m - Son of Thomas & Mary Dahill
DAHILL Timothy Sr. Spouse of Catherine. Born 1829, died 1876
DAILY Frank. Spouse of Mary C. Born 1919, died uncut
DAILY Mary Corman. Spouse of Frank. Born 1827, died 1890 - His Wife
DAVIS Mary - Dates are underground
DEAN Anthony. Spouse of Margaret. Born 1822, died 1901
DEAN Anthony C. Born 11-15-1846, died 9-2-1905
DEAN Bartholomew, died 10-29-1879. Age: 22
DEAN Bridget. Spouse of Patrick. Born 1815, died 1897 - His Wife
DEAN Catherine. Born 1846, died uncut
DEAN Elizabeth. Born 1868, died 1913
DEAN John. Born 1860, died 1951
DEAN Margaret. Spouse of Anthony. Born 1822, died 1901 - His Wife
DEAN Margaret - no other info
DEAN Marion Rose. Born 1917, died 1927. Age: 10y - Daughter
DEAN Mary T. Born 1877, died 1928
DEAN Michael. Spouse of Teressa. Born 1842, died 1913
DEAN Patrick. Spouse of Bridget. Born 1812, died 1890
DEAN Patrick A. Born 1845, died 1924
DEAN Teressa. Spouse of Michael. Born 1844, died 1900
DEAN Vincent. Born 1913, died 1919 - Son of Micheal &Teressa
DEAN William. Born 1879, died 1895 - Son of Patrick A & K Dean
DeLANG Patrick. Born 1853, died 1910
DeLANY Catherine. Spouse of Patrick. Born 1810, died 1904 - His wife
DeLANY Patrick. Spouse of Catherine. Born 1808, died 1886
DeLANY William. Born 1880, died 1896
DIXON Anthony. Spouse of Ohnar M. Born 5-20-1822, died 10-5-1902 - May their souls rest in peace
DIXON Ohnar McAndrew. Spouse of Anthony. Born 10-10-1842, died 3-15-1902 - His Wife
DOHERTY Edward. Born 1885, died 1908
DONNELLY Edward L. Born 1877, died 1919
DORAN Barney. Born 5-5-1838, died 12-14-1916 - Civil War Vet, Co D 1st PA Rifles and 19th PA Cav.
DORAN Bartholomew - no other info
DORAN Bartley. Spouse of Bridget. Born 1834, died uncut
DORAN Bridget. Spouse of Bartley. Born 1837, died 1914 - His Wife
DORAN Eliza. Born 1861, died 1928
DORAN John - no other info
DOUGHERTY Bridget. Spouse of Peter. Born 1834, died 1918
DOUGHERTY James F. Born 1875, died 1916
DOUGHERTY Mary. Born 1867, died 1869
DOUGHERTY Patrick J. Born 1854, died 1928 - Father
DOUGHERTY Peter. Spouse of Bridget. Born 1822, died 1910 - Born in Ireland
DRAKE John - Stone broken badly
DRISCOLL Mortimer J. Born 10-8-1887, died 9-16-1932 - WW I Vet, 307 Field 7th Div, Pvt.
DUMMINGS George W. Born 1858, died 1925
FISHER John. Spouse of Margaret J. Born 1854, died 1909
FISHER Margaret J Trainor. Spouse of John. Born 1857, died 1927 - His Wife
FLYNN Ann. Spouse of Michael Sr. Born 1825, died 1896
FLYNN Anna. Born 1900, died 1907
FLYNN Michael Sr. Spouse of Ann. Born 1814, died 1896
FLYNN Michael P. Spouse of Rose E. Born 1859, died 1940
FLYNN Rose E. Spouse of Michael P. Born 1869, died 1940
GALLAGHER Bridget. Spouse of James, died 1-28-1882. Age: 72y - His Wife
GALLAGHER Emmett A. Age: 3m - Son of James & Bridget Gallagher
GALLAGHER James. Spouse of Bridget, died 9-25-1885. Age: 82y
GALLAGHER James. Born 1844, died 1899
GALLAGHER John H. Age: 18m - Son of James & Bridget Gallagher
GALLAGHER Mary. Born 1890, died 1891
GALLAGHER Patrick. Born 1858, died 1906
GARVIN Frances, died 12-2-1913 - Son of Mr & Mrs MT Garvin
GARVIN Patrick, died 5-16-1879. Age: 37y
GARVIN Peter, died 1-20-1896. Age: 22y - Son of Patrick &Bridget Garvin
GAVIN Catharine. Spouse of James. Born 1828, died 1914 - His Wife
GAVIN James. Spouse of Catharine. Born 1827, died 1912
GILLEN Celia. Spouse of Michael. Born 1822, died 1912 - His Wife
GILLEN Michael. Spouse of Celia. Born 1808, died 1890 - Military stone says born 1810 - Civil War Vet, Co D 54th Inf, NYS Vols, Cpl. Mustered in 9-1-1663 for three years. Mustered out with company 4-14-1866 at Charleston SC.
GILLEN Michael Jr. Born 1851, died 1875 - Son of Michael & Celia Gillen
GRAVIN Margaret A. Born 1894, died 1895 - Dau of Peter & Ettie Gravin
GREENE Garrett, died 4-30-1884. Age: 47y - Of Greenwood
HALLETT Frank. Born 1870, died 1915
HALLETT Margaret. Born 1872, died uncut
HALSEY Joseph. Born 1864, died 1918
HALSEY Mary. Spouse of William. Born 1828, died 1907
HANDY Mary. Spouse of Frank. Born 1860, died 1920
HARRINGTON Jeremiah - May His Soul Rest In Peace Amen
HARRIS Agnes. Born 1875, died 1957
HASLEY Mary A. Born 1855, died 1878
HASLEY William. Spouse of Mary. Born 1828, died 1904
HORAN Ellen Dean. Spouse of Henry. Born 3-29-1853, died 2-9-1913 - Mother
HORAN Frank H. Born 1891, died 1922
HORAN Henry. Spouse of Ellen Dean. Born 5-29-1854, died 12-6-1942 - Father
HORAN Henry. Spouse of Mary, died 6-3-1902. Age: 84y
HORAN John, died 3-12-1892. Age: 16y - Son of Henry & Ellen Horan
HORAN Mary. Spouse of Henry, died 7-25-1892. Age: 75y - His Wife
HORAN Nellie A. Born 1880, died 1932
HORAN Sarah. Spouse of Martin, died 5-7-1880. Age: 80y
HOWE Ellen, died 6-26-1878. Age: 25y 2m - Dau of Owen & Francis Howe
HOWE Francis. Spouse of Owen. Born 1825, died ? - date underground
HOWE John. Spouse of Mary S. Born 4-17-1829-, died 9-11-1916 - Monument states 1832 as birth year - Civil War Vet, Co E 1st Dragoons NYS Vols, Pvt. Enlisted 8-9-1862 at Andover for three years. Mustered out with Company 6-30-1865 at Clouds Mills VA.
HOWE Mary Sheridan. Spouse of John. Born 1839, died 1910 - His Wife
HOWE Owen. Spouse of Francis. Born 1825, died 1902
HURST Catherine. Born 1857, died 1928
HURST George E. Born 1849, died 1922
HURST John. Born 1818, died 1893
HYLAND Ellen. Born 1825, died 1898
HYLAND Timothy. Born 1899, died 1913 - Son of Patrick & Cecelia Hyland
HYLAND Timothy. Born 1819, died 1892
JOYCE Anthony - No other info
JOYCE James. Born 1862, died 1929
JOYCE Joseph - No other info
JOYCE Kathryn G. Born 1862, died 1951
JOYCE Margaret. Born 1860, died 1904
JOYCE Margaret (Little). Born 1903, died 1904
JOYCE Mary. Spouse of Thomas. Born 1870, died 1945
JOYCE Mother. Born 1840, died ? - stone underground
JOYCE Thomas. Spouse of Mary. Born 1860, died 1936
KEOUGH Catherine Sullivan. Spouse of Stephen. Born 1834, died 4-11-1896 - His Wife
KEOUGH Stephen. Spouse of Catherine S. Born 1825, died 8-28-1904
KILBANE Anthony, died Infant
KILBANE Ellen, died Infant
KILBANE John. Spouse of Margaret, died 4-11-1921
KILBANE Margaret. Spouse of John, died 4-30-1885. Age: 45y - Born In Ireland
KILBANE Martin, died 9-6-1886
KILBANE Patrick, died 10-30-1923
KING Agnes, died 4-12-1889. Age: 79y11m16d
LAVELL Bridget. Spouse of Patrick, died 1-8-1899. Age: 75y 9m - His Wife
LAVELL Bridget, died 8-13-1878. Age: 24y 2m - Dau of Patrick & Bridget Lavell
LAVELL John, died 3-12-1865. Age: 9y 1m - Son of Patrick & Bridget Lavell
LAVELL Patrick. Spouse of Bridget, died 4-20-1884. Age: 87y 3m 22d
LYNCH Ann McTighe. Spouse of Terrence. Born 1823, died 1910 - His Wife
LYNCH Anthony. Born 7-26-1814, died 7-25-1891
LYNCH Austin. Born 4-11-1857, died 8-24-1905
LYNCH Bridget. Born 10-5-1833, died 1-31-1907
LYNCH Celia. Spouse of Martin. Born 1838, died uncut
LYNCH Celia G. Spouse of Michael T. Born 10-1-1854, died 10-2-1900
LYNCH Daniel. Born 1888, died 1927
LYNCH Delia E. Born 10-10-1864, died 7-13-1925
LYNCH John L Rev Father. Born 7-2-1894, died 12-12-1921 - Ordained Nov 2 1919
LYNCH John T, died 12-25-1882. Age: 16y - Son of M & N Lynch
LYNCH Maggie. Born 7-12-1859, died 12-11-1895 - Sister to Annie Lynch Pierce
LYNCH Martin. Spouse of Celia. Born 1835, died 1899
LYNCH Michael. Born 1861, died 1920 - Son of Michael & Ellen Lynch
LYNCH Michael Sr, died 3-7-1890. Age: 74y
LYNCH Michael T. Spouse of Celia G. Born 12-2-1853, died 4-18-1939
LYNCH Peter. Born 1857, died 1919
LYNCH Robert E. Born 1889, died 1892 - Son of Martin and Celia Lynch
LYNCH Terrence. Spouse of Ann M. Born 1820, died 1876
LYNCH Thomas Michael. Born 10-31-1895, died 8-10-1918. Age: 22 - Son of Austin and Caterin (Padder) Lynch. Born in Chicago IL,killed in France. - WW I KIA, US Army, 4th Div. Sgt. Killed in Battle of Vesle River France
LYNCH Veronica, died 8-3-1899. Age: 1 day - Dau of Pl & E G Lynch
McANDREW Elizabeth A. Spouse of William J. Born 1862, died 1945
McANDREW Evelyn. Born 1883, died 1924 - Dau of Richard McAndrew
McANDREW Mary. Born 1887, died 1906
McANDREW Mother. Spouse of Richard. Born 1845, died 1923
McANDREW Richard. Born 1876, died 1877 - Son of Richard McAndrew
McANDREW Richard. Spouse of Mother. Born 1844, died 1928
McANDREW Veronica. Born 1888, died 1907
McANDREW William J. Spouse of Elizabeth A. Born 1858, died 1922
McCARTHY Charles, died 10-1-1880. Age: 20y 8m - Son of Timothy & Ellen McCarthy
McCARTHY Patrick, died 6-18-1878. Age: 16y - Son of Timothy & Ellen McCarthy
McCORMICK Quines Lynch - no other info
McGINTY Catherine. Spouse of James. Born 1840, died 1923
McGINTY James. Spouse of Catherine. Born 1834, died 1914
McGINTY John Joseph, died 8-21-1888. Age: 21y4m18d
McGINTY Manas G, died 7-2-1889. Age: 36y 7m 12d
McLAUGHLIN Francis, died 6-23-1867. Age: 6y 10 m 16d - Son of John & Sarah McLaughlin
McLAUGHLIN John. Spouse of Sarah, died 1-24-1899. Age: 68y
McLAUGHLIN Margaret. Spouse of Patrick - No other info
McLAUGHLIN Patrick. Spouse of Patrick. Born 1829, died 1897 - His Wife
McLAUGHLIN Sarah. Spouse of John, died 9-20-1895. Age: 61y
McMAHAN James, died 12-4-1873. Age: 57y
McTIGHE Catherine E. Born 1852, died 1935
McTIGHE Inez. Born 1888, died 1890
McTIGHE James. Spouse of Mary C. Born 1865, died 1898 - Father
McTIGHE James. Born 1820, died 1890
McTIGHE John. Born 1867, died 1905
McTIGHE Mary C. Spouse of James. Born 1862, died 1930 - Mother
McTIGHE Mary Howe. Born 1825, died 1888
McTIGHE Rose. Born 1863, died 1892
MILES Alice. Spouse of Bryan - His Wife no other info
MILES Bryan. Spouse of Alice, died 2-5-1882. Age: 45y
MITCHELL Catharine W. Spouse of John, died 6-6-1906. Age: 66y
MULGAHY Ella. Born 1891, died 1951
MULGAHY Francis, died 1899. Age: 3m
MULGAHY James. Born 1894, died 1918
MULGAHY Mary. Spouse of Patrick Sr. Born 1856, died 1932 - Mother
MULGAHY Mary, died 1893. Age: 5m
MULGAHY Patrick Jr. Born 1878, died 1901
MULGAHY Patrick Sr. Spouse of Mary. Born 1847, died 1924 - Father
MULGAHY Thomas. Born 1883, died 1935
MULGAHY William. Born 1889, died 1926
NIEDERMAIER Elizabeth. Born 1924, died 1926
NIEDERMAIER Marlene T. Born 1956, died 1957
O'BOYLE Catharine E - Dau of Richard & Ellen O'Boyle
O'BOYLE Ellen. Born 1851, died 1927 - His Wife
O'BOYLE Ellen I - Dau of Richard & Ellen O'Boyle
O'BOYLE John A - Son of Richard & Ellen O'Boyle
O'BOYLE Lambert - Son of Richard & Ellen O'Boyle
O'BOYLE Patrick, died 10-6-1918
O'BOYLE Richard. Spouse of Ellen, died 7-23-1898. Age: 49y
O'BOYLE Richard J - Son of Richard & Ellen O'Boyle
O'BOYLE Sarah, died 5-11-1913
O'BOYLE William, died 9-19-1890. Age: 82y
O'BOYLE William. Born 1872, died 1918
O'DONNELL Celia. Spouse of Thomas, died 4-1-1892. Age: 76y - Mother" May Her Soul Rest In Peace
O'DONNELL Domnick. Spouse of Mary, died 6-12-1876. Age: 88y
O'DONNELL Martin. Spouse of Mary Ellen. Born 1858, died 1950
O'DONNELL Mary. Spouse of Domnick, died 3-8-1871. Age: 76y - His Wife
O'DONNELL Mary. Spouse of M. - Wife of no other info
O'DONNELL Mary. Born 1858, died 1929
O'DONNELL Mary Ellen. Spouse of Martin. Born 10-9-1858, died 12-10-1891
O'DONNELL Thomas. Spouse of Celia. Born 1810, died 1910 - Father
O'DONNELL Thomas J. Born Jan.1862, died 12-20-1900 - Son of Thomas & Celia O'Donnell
O'LEARY Anna. Born 1861, died 1934
O'LEARY James. Spouse of Margaret. Born 1823, died 1903
O'LEARY James A. Born 1863, died 1948
O'LEARY Josephine C Oakley. Born 1863, died 1921
O'LEARY Margaret. Spouse of James, died 12-4-1892. Age: 64y - His Wife
O'LEARY Margaret. Born 1862, died 1901
O'LEARY Mary M. Born 1894, died 1986
O'NEIL William, died 7-21-1861. Age: 22y 11m - Farewell Dear Husband Thou art gone and left me here alone.
PADDEN Edward J. Born 1-3-1864, died 3-10-1892 - Son of Hulbert & Margaret Padden
PADDEN Patrick - Rest In Peace
PADDEN Patrick. Born 12-20-1832, died 4-10-1905
PARDON Mary B. Spouse of William A. Born 1869, died uncut
PARDON William A. Spouse of Mary B. Born 1864, died 1924
PATTEN Michael. Born 9-28-1865, died 1-7-1898
PATTEN Owen R. Born 1858, died 1880
PATTEN Sarah S. Born 1801, died 1893
PIERCE Annie Lynch. Spouse of Frank. Born 1-12-1865, died 4-29-1901
REGAN Ellen. Spouse of Patrick - His Wife no other info
REGAN Ellen, died 8-12-1867. Age: 27y - Dau of Patrick & Ellen Regan
REGAN Mary, died 3-25-1883. Age: 21y - Dau of Patrick & Ellen Regan
REGAN Patrick. Spouse of Ellen, died 9-9-1889. Age: 68y
REGAN Patrick. Born 1861, died 1925
REGAN Thomas. Born 1870, died 1950
RILEY Edward. Born 1881, died 1909
RILEY James O. Spouse of Margaret, died 5-6-1883. Age: 74y - May the Lord Have Mercy on His Soul
RILEY Margaret. Spouse of James O - His Wife
RILEY Mary A. Born 1856, died 1914
RILEY Thomas. Born 1845, died uncut
ROURKE children - Children of Timothy & Bridget Rourke
SHIELDS Francis. Born 1882, died 1888 - Son of Michael & Mary Shields
SHIELDS Mary A. Dean. Spouse of Michael S. Born 1844, died 1914 - His Wife
SHIELDS Michael S. Spouse of Mary A. Born 1838, died 1909 - Civil War Vet, Co E 72nd Inf NYS Vols, Cpl. Enlisted 5-16-1861 at Dunkirk for three years. Wounded in action 7-1-1862 at Malvern Nill VA and 7-2-1863 at Gettysburg. Discharged for wounds 12-11-1863 from hospital at Newark NJ.
TRAINER Mary, died 5-13-1883. Age: 5y 2m - Dau of John & Ellen Trainor Parents name spelled with o
TRAINOR Agnes - No other info
TRAINOR Ellen. Spouse of John. Born 1855, died 1919
TRAINOR John. Spouse of Ellen. Born 1841, died 1919
TRAINOR Thomas. Born 1826, died 1898
WAHL Mary T Horan. Spouse of John. Born 1875, died 1932
WALSH Edward. Spouse of Mary. Born 1810, died 1879 - Father
WALSH Mary. Spouse of Edward. Born 1818, died 1888 - Mother
WALSH Owen. Born 5-9-1854, died 1-17-1908
WALSH Richard. Born 1840, died 1861
WHITE ---------, died 8-2-1812 - unreadable

Back to Allegany County



If you have anything of genealogical or historical interest to add to this site, or if you are interested in becoming a member of the Painted Hills Genealogy Society, please contact us at:
Painted Hills

This page is maintained by the PHGS
Last Update November 19, 2022