This Cemetery is Abandoned. In very bad shape with downed trees, broken
fence and overgrown.
Many of the stones are broken and on the ground, very black from age.
Some are upright and were easy to read.
It probably is scattered over an area of 200 x 200 (just guessing).
BAKER, Andrew spouse of Laura L. died 12-19-1879 age 61y
Co. 1 85 Retg N.Y.V.
BAKER, Andrew died 4-10-1844 age 80y
BAKER, Laura L. spouse of Andrew died U/C
BOYD, Mary E. Crandall spouse of Gordon died 1-1-1883 age 19y
BROWN, Prudence D. spouse of Samuel died 7-29-1870 age 43y 6m
BROWN, Samuel spouse of Prudence D. born 7-2-1824 died 2-1-1895
BROWN, Sarah C. spouse of William H. died 10-11-1866 age 18y
BROWN, Simey W. died 10-25-1886 age 7y 6m 22d Son of W. H. & J. Brown
COOPER, Mary spouse of Zerah died 12-25-1882 age 62y
COOPER, Zerah died 5-3-1878
CRANDALL, Polly spouse of Francis died 12-7-1885 age 59y
EVERETT, George died 10-26-1870 age 60y 3m 9d
FARWELL, James spouse of Orrilla born 6-20-1807 died 7-5-1884 age 77y 2m 16d Born at Fitchburg, Mass.
FARWELL, Miner died 1-3-1879 age 25y 10m 3d MY HUSBAND
FARWELL, Orrilla spouse of James born 7-28-1826 died 7-25-1893
FULLER, Andrew J. spouse of Emeline died 5-16-1883 age 47y 4m 25d
FULLER, Emeline spouse of Andrew J. died 4-9-1866 age 29y 24d
FULLER, Emeline spouse of L. L. Fuller died 4-9-1866
FULLER, Phebe spouse of William born 1-25-1828 died 8-18-1886
HARDING, U/K Son of Foster & Retta Harding could not read rest of stone
JOHNSON, Charles G. spouse of Sarah A. born 2-21-1824 died 3-14-1898
JOHNSON, Rebecca died 4-9-1888
JOHNSON, Rev. Eliprelet died 1-20-1876 age 83y 5d
JOHNSON, Sarah A. spouse of Charles G. born 3-17-1829 died 6-17-1879
McELROY, Annie spouse of James born 1828 died 1898
McELROY, Annie V. born 1867 died 1880 age 13y Dau. of James & Annie McElroy
McELROY, Carrie born 1871 died 1900 Dau. of James & Annie McElroy
McELROY, James spouse of Annie born 1829 died 1891
McGIBENY, Andrew born 2-14-1829 died 1-14-1865 Son of George & Anna McGibeny Soldier of the War of 1861
McGIBENY, Anna spouse of George born 11-28-1799 died 5-9-1869
McGIBENY, George spouse of Anna born 12-24-1794 died 2-14-1891
McGIBENY, George B. born 7-14-1834 died 4-1-1866 age 31y 8m 17d Son of George & Anna McGibeny Co. 1 85 Regt N.Y.S. Vol. GAR 61-65
McGIBENY, John born 1-11-1827 died 8-23-1850 age 23y 6m 2d
MULLIGAN, Mark died 4-17-1896 age 1y 2m
STUCK, Abbie J. died 6-11-1895 age 5m
STUCK, Archie born 1898 died 1899
STUCK, May J. spouse of Willis born 1874 died 1899 AT REST
STUCK, May M. died 3-17-1900 age 4m
TULLER, Rev. James H. born 7-10-1828 died 3-29-1890
If you have anything of genealogical or historical interest to add to this site, or if you are interested in becoming a member of the Painted Hills Genealogy Society, please contact us at:
This page is maintained by the PHGS
Last Update February 11, 2020